Updated October 19, 2026 · Shops, seasons and shipping checked with each fudge maker and the Mackinac Island Tourism Bureau; reviews read
Northern Michigan runs on fudge. Kilwins started in Petoskey in 1947, Murdick’s has been making it on Mackinac Island since 1887, and the island’s shops turn out about five tons a day in peak season. You don’t need the ferry to get good fudge, though: Howse’s has been making it in downtown Harbor Springs since 1959, about 10 minutes from The Bird House, and two Petoskey shops make it in-house about 15 minutes away. Here’s where to go, where to watch it made and how to get it home.
The Bird House sleeps 11, about 10 minutes from Howse’s Fudge in Harbor Springs.
Season note: most Mackinac Island fudge shops close for winter at the end of October (Ryba’s island shops closed October 25 in 2026), and Kilwins Harbor Springs currently shows as closed. Howse’s in Harbor Springs is open year-round, and the Petoskey shops and online ordering keep the fudge coming all year.
Where to get fudge near Harbor Springs
Tap a filter.
Howse’s Fudge
201 E. Main St., Harbor Springs · ~10 min
The closest fudge to the house and a Harbor Springs original since 1959, in a downtown shop from about 1908. Over 20 flavors of fudge plus caramels, turtles and brittle, made on site; the classic plain chocolate has been the best seller for about 60 years. Open year-round and ships daily: (800) 813-1845.
Howse’s Fudge →Murdick’s Fudge of Petoskey
311 Howard St. · ~15 min
Everything is made in-house here, fudge and caramel corn included. It ships, with free shipping on orders of $75 or more. Summer hours run late; call for fall and winter hours.
Murdick’s Petoskey →Kilwins Petoskey
316 Howard St. · ~15 min
In the town where Kilwins began in 1947: fudge made in copper kettles, hand-paddled and cooled on marble tables. Open 11 to 9 daily.
Kilwins Petoskey →Kilwins Chocolate Kitchen
1050 Bay View Rd., Petoskey
Fudge made in the store, viewing windows into the kitchen, and free guided tours that Kilwins lists Monday to Thursday at 1:30. Open 10 to 8 daily. Call (231) 347-7112 to confirm the tour.
Chocolate Kitchen →Kilwins Harbor Springs
139 E. Main St. · ~10 min
Seasonal, and currently showing as closed on Kilwins’ own page. Call (231) 526-9871 before you go.
Store page →Murdick’s, Mackinac Island
7363 Main St.
Founded in 1887 as Mackinac Island’s first candy shop. The Tourism Bureau credits Rome Murdick as the first on the island to make fudge on marble slabs, and the slabs are in the storefront. Ships anywhere in the U.S. year-round.
Murdick’s →Ryba’s
Five shops on Mackinac Island
Fudge made by hand on marble slabs. The island shops are closed for winter (the 2026 season ended October 25); online orders ship free over $99.
Ryba’s →JoAnn’s Fudge
Two island shops + 303 E. Central Ave., Mackinaw City
Making fudge since 1969, poured on marble slabs, with online ordering year-round. The Mackinaw City shop is rated 4.7 from about 790 Google reviews.
JoAnn’s →May’s Candy Shop
Mackinac Island
Pure Michigan calls May’s the oldest fudge shop on the island today, and the only one visited by an American president.
Pure Michigan →Marshall’s Fudge
308 E. Central Ave., Mackinaw City
Making fudge since 1923, with marble tables, and the Mackinaw City store is open year-round. A good stop when the island is closed.
Marshall’s →Murdick’s, Mackinaw City
219 E. Central Ave.
On the Mackinaw City side of the bridge. One reviewer’s tip: the salted caramel is their best seller.
Murdick’s →Fall Fudge Festival
Mackinac Island, October 1–2, 2027
The island’s fall fudge festival, held in early October; the 2027 dates are posted.
Festival info →Showing 12 shops
We read the reviews for every shop listed; none showed a pattern of rude service.
“By-far the most kid-friendly rental we have ever stayed at.” Steve S., Union, KY, August 2026
See open dates →A fudge day from the house
- Evening: Downtown Harbor Springs, about 10 minutes from the house: Howse’s Fudge on Main Street, then a walk to the marina.
- Take home: A box of the classic chocolate; it’s been their best seller for about 60 years.
- 2:00: Downtown Petoskey, about 15 minutes from the house: Kilwins and Murdick’s, both on Howard Street.
- 3:00: Bayfront Park’s playground to burn off the sugar.
- Weekday: Add the Kilwins Chocolate Kitchen on Bay View Road to watch it made.
- Morning: Mackinaw City ferry dock, about 37 minutes from the house.
- On the island: Watch the marble slabs at Murdick’s, then compare Ryba’s, JoAnn’s and May’s.
- Back on the mainland: Marshall’s or JoAnn’s in Mackinaw City if you forgot the gift box.
- More: Our Mackinac day-trip guide.
- Keep: Wrapped airtight at room temperature, up to three weeks.
- Don’t: Refrigerate it.
- Freeze: Up to six months; thaw at room temperature.
- Order: Howse’s, Murdick’s, Ryba’s and JoAnn’s all ship.
Fudge tips
Fudge keeps up to three weeks wrapped airtight at room temperature, according to JoAnn’s. Don’t refrigerate it; it dries out. Freeze it for up to six months and thaw at room temperature.
And for the ice cream side: best ice cream near Harbor Springs.
Northern Michigan fudge: quick answers
Where can you buy fudge in Harbor Springs?
Howse's Fudge at 201 East Main Street, making fudge on site since 1959 and open year-round, about 10 minutes from The Bird House. In Petoskey, about 15 minutes away, Murdick's and Kilwins on Howard Street both make it in-house.
Where can you watch fudge being made near Petoskey?
Kilwins Petoskey cools its fudge on marble tables, and the Kilwins Chocolate Kitchen on Bay View Road has viewing windows and free tours Monday to Thursday.
How many fudge shops are on Mackinac Island?
The Mackinac Island Tourism Bureau counts 13, making about 10,000 pounds a day at the peak of the season.
What is the oldest fudge shop on Mackinac Island?
Murdick's dates to 1887 as the island's first candy shop. Pure Michigan calls May's the oldest fudge shop operating on the island today.
Are Mackinac Island fudge shops open in winter?
Most close for the winter at the end of October. Howse's in Harbor Springs and Marshall's in Mackinaw City are open year-round, and Murdick's, Ryba's and JoAnn's sell online.
How long does fudge last?
JoAnn's says up to three weeks wrapped airtight at room temperature, or up to six months frozen. Don't refrigerate it.
Fudge by day, fire pit by night
The Bird House sleeps 11 in five bedrooms, about 10 minutes from Howse’s Fudge, 15 from the Petoskey shops and 37 from the Mackinaw City ferry dock, with a fire pit, eight Adirondack chairs and a hot tub for the end of the day. Pick your dates and see the full total before you commit.
Questions first? Call our property manager at (231) 347-7300.