Best Ice Cream Near Harbor Springs and Petoskey (2026)

Downtown Harbor Springs, Michigan — Main Street shops and church steeple on a summer day

Updated October 19, 2026 · Every shop checked for 2026: open or closed, hours, and reviews

Ice cream after dinner is half the point of a northern Michigan trip. Near the house, it’s Yummies in downtown Harbor Springs and the Kilwins and Murdick’s shops on Howard Street in Petoskey, where Kilwins started in 1947. Farther out, Mackinac Island and Traverse City’s Moomers are worth the drive. Here’s what’s open, what to order and how to fit it into an evening.

The Bird House sleeps 11, about 10 minutes from downtown Harbor Springs and 15 from downtown Petoskey.

~10 minto Yummies, downtown Harbor Springs
60+flavors at Yummies (cash only)
Since 1947Kilwins began in Petoskey
150+flavors made at Moomers

Two updates for 2026: The Dairy Zone on M-119 has closed for good, and Kilwins in Harbor Springs is seasonal and currently shows as closed, so call (231) 526-9871 before you go. Yummies is cash only.

The best ice cream near Harbor Springs

Tap a filter.

Yummies

Downtown Harbor Springs · ~10 min

The Harbor Springs ice cream stop since 1997: over 60 ice creams plus gelato, malts and shakes. Cash only. Current hours are noon to 8, and to 9 on Friday and Saturday. Rated 4.5 on TripAdvisor.

Yummies →

Kilwins Harbor Springs

139 E. Main St. · ~10 min

Seasonal; it currently shows as closed on Kilwins’ own store page, so call (231) 526-9871 before you count on it. Fudge and ice cream when it’s open.

Store page →

Kilwins Petoskey

316 Howard St. · ~15 min

The downtown Petoskey shop in the town where Kilwins began as a bakery in 1947. Open 11 to 9 daily.

Kilwins Petoskey →

Murdick’s Fudge and Ice Cream

311 Howard St. · ~15 min

Also on Howard Street, with homemade ice cream; reviewers single out the strawberry and chocolate. Do a two-shop taste test.

Reviews →

Kilwins Chocolate Kitchen

1050 Bay View Rd., Petoskey

Kilwins’ chocolate kitchen serves ice cream, open 10 to 8 daily, with free tours Monday to Thursday. Tour times have been listed differently in different places, so call (231) 347-7112.

Chocolate Kitchen →

Tom’s Mom’s Cookies

Downtown Harbor Springs · ~10 min

Not ice cream, but the other required sweet in Harbor Springs, and open year-round.

Tom’s Mom’s guide →

Howse’s Fudge

201 E. Main St., Harbor Springs · ~10 min

Not ice cream, but the fudge stop in Harbor Springs since 1959: over 20 flavors made on site, open year-round. More fudge in our fudge guide.

Fudge guide →

Sadie’s Ice Cream Parlor

Mackinac Island · ferry ~37 min from the house

The Grand Hotel’s parlor, now serving Guernsey Farms Dairy ice cream, at 1891 Cadotte Ave. and in the Grand Hotel market on Main Street. The 2026 season ends October 24.

Sadie’s →

Kilwins Charlevoix

233 Bridge St., Charlevoix

Open late: 11 to 10 Sunday to Thursday, 11 to 11 Friday and Saturday. A good finish to a Charlevoix afternoon.

Kilwins Charlevoix →

Moomers Homemade Ice Cream

Traverse City · a long drive

More than 150 homemade flavors with 20-plus in the case each day; Cherries Moobilee and Cow Tracks are the famous ones. Open daily 11 to 8 in season. Rated 4.8 from more than 4,600 Google reviews.

Moomers →

Showing 10 shops

We read every shop’s reviews before listing it. Seasonal hours change; call ahead in spring and fall.

“By-far the most kid-friendly rental we have ever stayed at.” Steve S., Union, KY, August 2026

See open dates →

How to fit ice cream into the day

  • 6:00: Early dinner; see our where to eat guide.
  • 7:00: Yummies on Main Street, about 10 minutes from the house. Bring cash.
  • 7:30: Walk it to the marina and Zorn Park.
  • 2:00: Downtown Petoskey, about 15 minutes away: Kilwins and Murdick’s, both on Howard Street.
  • 3:00: Bayfront Park’s playground.
  • Rainy version: The Kilwins Chocolate Kitchen on Bay View Road; call about tours.
  • Morning: Mackinaw City ferry dock, about 37 minutes from the house.
  • Afternoon: Sadie’s for a sundae (seasonal: closed for winter, back when the island reopens in spring).
  • More: Our Mackinac day-trip guide.

Ice cream run tips

Summer lines are longest right after dinner. Go a little earlier, or get it to go and eat it by the water.

Make it a night out: see where to eat with kids.

0 of 6 done

Ice cream near Harbor Springs: quick answers

Where is the best ice cream in Harbor Springs?

Yummies on Main Street, with over 60 flavors plus gelato, malts and shakes. It's cash only and about 10 minutes from The Bird House.

Is Kilwins in Harbor Springs open?

It's seasonal and currently shows as closed on Kilwins' store page, so call (231) 526-9871 before you go. Kilwins Petoskey on Howard Street is open daily.

Is The Dairy Zone in Petoskey still open?

No. The Dairy Zone on M-119 has closed permanently.

Where can you get ice cream in Petoskey?

Kilwins and Murdick's on Howard Street downtown, and the Kilwins Chocolate Kitchen on Bay View Road.

What is the best ice cream on Mackinac Island?

Sadie's Ice Cream Parlor, run by the Grand Hotel, now serving Guernsey Farms Dairy ice cream. Its 2026 season ends October 24.

Is Moomers worth the drive?

If you're in Traverse City, yes: more than 150 homemade flavors and a 4.8 rating from thousands of reviews.

Base your sweet-tooth tour in one place

The Bird House sleeps 11 in five bedrooms, about 10 minutes from Yummies in Harbor Springs and 15 from the Petoskey shops, with a fully stocked kitchen and a fire pit for the end of the night. Pick your dates and see the full total before you commit.

Check Availability →

Questions first? Call our property manager at (231) 347-7300.